News & Comment

22 October 2006

Filed under News & Comment

Africa: celebrity and salvation

Africa: celebrity and salvation

More than twenty years ago Bob Geldof and I shared what turned out to be a case of wishful thinking.

We believed that the millions of pounds raised by Band Aid in a response to the famine that was wracking Ethiopia would go towards ensuring that never again would we look at our television screens and see emaciated figures, the consequence of famine, dying.

Since then, as Africa's crisis has deepened, Bob Geldof and I have gone our separate ways. The Irish rock star, businessman and philanthropist has continued to devote many of his energies to African causes, from membership of the British government's Commission for Africa to a leading role in organising the Live Aid concerts that accompanied the G8 summit in Gleneagles in July 2005. And he collected a knighthood along the way.

Geldof, then, is a pioneer of Celebrity Aid, though in seeking to draw the rich world's attention to the plight of the African poor, even this larger-than-life character stands on the shoulders of earlier figures such as Danny Kaye, the first ambassador for the United Nations Children's Fund [Unicef] in 1954.

Since Geldof's Ethiopian epiphany in 1984, more celebrities have joined the cause of Africa's recovery, from Kate Moss to Bono, Angelina Jolie to Chris Martin. Now they have been joined by Madonna (and her film-director husband Guy Ritchie), whose adoption of a boy from Malawi has created a media furore.

Sir Bob himself has helped raise more for Africa through Live Aid, and saved the continent's governments further huge sums by throwing his weight behind debt relief for some of the world's poorest countries. More than that, he has kept Africa's crisis high on the international agenda - or at least higher than it otherwise would have been - through ceaseless lobbying, a powerful personality and deep compassion.

All this while, I have done little more than send back to the Financial Times increasingly sceptical reports from Africa's development frontline about the benefits of aid, and questioned the role of the thousands of foreign-based or foreign-funded non-governmental organisations (NGOs) that have proliferated across the continent.

And now, a generation after our Ethiopian experience, I find it hard to find much we agree on.

I believe that debt relief without the toughest of conditions will fail; that to provide more aid is to send good money after bad; and that although the report of the Africa commission on which Geldof served is an invaluable source of information, it failed to address the fundamental question about the failure of aid.

 

 

The trap of cynicism

Like the poor, celebrities have always been with us. And as long as Africa remains a scar on the conscience of the west, as somebody once said, I expect they will stay with us. On either side of this great divide of life-experience and life-chances, this is one area where there is no prospect of any supply problems.

The celeb phenomenon has been around as long as the African continent has been in trouble; but it has increased in velocity since the problems of poverty, illness and dependency became more broadly exposed to the world's eyes in the first decades after independence.

As Hollywood's A-list finest such as Audrey Hepburn have been supplemented by a far wider range of figures from the worlds of pop music, television and football, as well as film, there is as much chance of stopping the southward flow of glamour as there is of finding a quick fix for Africa.

For there is a lot to keep these celebs busy. At least 40% of the continent's 800 million people go to bed hungry each night. What is more, as the world hunger report published in October 2006 revealed, this number is increasing each year. Some 3 million African children die every year of preventable diseases before they reach the age of 5.

And that is just the human toll. The loss of biodiversity as a result of soil depletion, desertification, and forest clearance has meant that dozens of animal species have become endangered or extinct - creating a further space for conservationist celebs to enter and campaign to save favourite (and very often the most photogenic) creatures.

There are occasions when the accompanying media coverage - designed to entertain as well as raise concern among potential western aid-givers - is plainly insensitive and silly, as when Kate Moss "blacked up" for the Independent's special Africa supplement (though the blame falls as much on the journalist who thought it up as the model who went along with it). It is true too that some events or photo opportunities owe less to a compassionate heart than to attempts to boost a flagging career.

It also seems to me, however, that the frequent mockery and derision by journalists and others of Bono, Geldof, Madonna or any of the other celebs is insufferable arrogance. To say that they are motivated by a desire for further publicity, or that they are expressing their concern in an inappropriate way, is unwarranted.

The vice of aid

But it is possible to have concerns without falling into fashionable cynicism. I have three such.

First, there is a danger that the attention given to celebrities' involvement is a distraction from the debate that shouldbe taking place: about the fact that aid does not work in Africa.

That is surely beyond doubt. In Kenya, recipient of hundreds of millions of dollars in aid since independence in 1963, more of its citizens than ever are categorised as impoverished - around 55-60% - than when the flag of statehood was raised and Jomo Kenyatta installed as the country's founding president. True, life-expectancy has increased (though I suspect it is starting to decline), but an increase in longevity is scant return on aid investment if in other respects, life for millions of Kenyans remains nasty and brutish.

In this respect, there is surely the danger that those in the business of aid have lost sight of the purpose of aid.

The second, related concern is that the publicity surrounding celebrities tends to obscure discussion of whether aid has contributed to - or in some cases evencaused - Africa's problems.

Kenya's northeast, where aid has subsidised the settlement of people on land that never had the capacity to sustain them, is one prime case. Another is Sudan in the late 1980s and early 1990s. There, the United Nations programme to feed civilians caught in the country's north-south civil war (Operation Lifeline, established in April 1989) arguably did as much harm as good, by taking responsibility from the shoulders of the men who were leading the fighting.

Year after year food aid poured in to Sudan, until the process became institutionalised and the "aid" became an integral part of the wider conflict. A tough question was avoided: should the donors have in effect declared a cut-off point in the delivery of food aid, in order to try to concentrate the protagonists' minds on the peace process?

This would have been a terribly difficult decision to make, and if it had been it is certain that TV cameras would be present to record the last breaths of stick-limbed children. But the decision would have been no more difficult, nor more terrible in its consequences, than one to take a country into war.

The third concern is that the alliance of celebrity involvement and aid strategy in Africa is diminishing, or will diminish, the continent's self-confidence.

A post-independence generation of Africans says it does. From Andrew Rugasira, the Ugandan coffee entrepreneur, to John Githongo, the exiled anti-corruption campaigner from Kenya, to Moeletsi Mbeki, a leading South African businessman, comes the same answer: we don't need aid, we want a fair crack of the trade whip.

Part of their concern is the impact of aid on the role and the capacity of the state. Kenya (to stay with the example of the east African country, so long considered - though not any more - as one of Africa's relative "success stories") has been a food importer most years. I expect it always will be. Certainly the trend is not encouraging: the population has doubled since 1980, two-thirds of the country is arid or semi-arid, and the size of the averageshamba (small farm) has fallen by half since the 1970s.

I don't doubt that many people - more than a million - are going hungry in northern Kenya. But questions must be asked that tend to be evaded:

  • why are there so many people living in such an inhospitable part of the country in the first place?

  • has a population that was dominantly nomadic become settled? If so, how has it survived?

  • has donor aid unwittingly created or contributed to the problem that is entrenched or endemic?

  • will hunger continue, despite conventional aid efforts, as the years go by - and will there be more mouths to feed?

And even more critically:

  • is the donor/NGO presence doing more harm than good?

  • are aid donors, by taking on a responsibility for care, contributing to the atrophy of the Kenyan state, thus leaving it less and less capable of meeting its obligations to its citizens?

If the answer to the last two questions in particular is yes, even a heavily qualified yes, it should be followed by a question which goes to the heart of the billion-dollar development failure in Africa:

  • could the experience of northern Kenya provide insights that lead to a better understanding of the weakening of the state across Africa?

For - to explain the last point - if the state cannot deliver its side of the contract (provision of basic services including roads, healthcare, security and law-enforcement, and disaster relief) why should the citizen stay loyal? Why pay taxes - and ultimately, why not bribe? And as the state recedes, why not turn to regional and ethnic loyalties, or to the political "big man"?

The air of debate

What then should be done? The answer is not to scorn the celebs but to encourage them - precisely to initiate a much-needed debate on these three issues.

Just imagine if Bono said: We should be prepared to admit defeat and re-engage - but re-engage on differentterms. The process - of disengagement and re-engagement in turn - should take place over ten years. At the end of those ten years, any aid project should be conditional on matching funds from African sources.

Or if Bob Geldof declared that: Africahas capital tied up in land - so radicalfooking reform of land tenure isfooking essential.

Or if Roger Moore maintained that:Africa's ill-managed state pension-funds should be opened up to competitive managements.

Or if Madonna argued that: We should respond to the fact that the diaspora of Africa's educated is swollen by 60,000 a year. This has led to the bizarre, outrageous situation that more doctors who were trained in Malawi are practising in England's second city of Birmingham than in Malawi itself. If one of Malawi's main exports is health professionals, that is not in itself a bad thing - what is unacceptable is that there is no organised replenishment. But if visas cost the equivalent of what it costs to train them in the first place, and the money is spent on the schools and universities that produced them, Malawi could thrive.

If these and other celebrities made such statements - in tune with modern African realities and the lessons of the past forty years, rather than with the outdated nostrums of the aid industry - the result would be an opening of a space for discussion of Africa's real needs.

Whether the celebrities can say these things - or whether their armies of advisers and publicists and sponsors will allow them - we can all agree on one thing. To provide effectiveaid, as opposed to a response to a humanitarian appeal, and to ensure that it contributes to a self-sustaining recovery, is a difficult thing to achieve. Who better than celebrities to boost a debate on ways to do it?

Comments

This article talks lot about the African continent and their life style. I was really surprised to know that the still follow some customs which are started by their ancestor time. I appreciate the best essays news channel in taking the pain in doing research about these people and their live style and showing to the world.

Posted by Jose T. Rodriguez on 30th June 2018 at 07:31pm

agar saya dicuci otak dan membaca moral. Anda tidak link10 jual plat high tensile sm490ya jual plat kapal jual plat stainless ss304 jual plat stainless ss310 jual plat stainless ss316 jual plat sumihard jual round bar besi aisi 440s45c jual round bar scm440 jual steel rail jual steel sheet pile Supplier besi siku baja Supplier besi siku baja Agen besi h beam Agen pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan yang unik Supplier Atap Spandek Sni Toko Pipa Besi baja Supplier besi h beam baja Supplier besi beton bjku Toko besi siku baja Toko besi siku baja Agen besi wf Agen besi hollow undangan pernikahan ala jepang Supplier Plat Bordes Kembang Jual Pipa Besi baja Toko besi h beam baja Supplier besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Agen besi siku baja Agen besi siku baja Agen wiremesh Agen besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan arab Supplier Plat Besi Hitam Harga Pipa Besi baja Agen besi h beam baja Supplier besi beton ais Pabrik besi siku baja Pabrik besi siku baja Agen besi unp Agen besi wf baja undangan pernikahan ala jepang Supplier Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel Pabrik Pipa Besi baja Pabrik besi h beam baja Supplier besi beton Distributor besi wf Distributor besi wf Agen besi cnp Agen besi unp undangan pernikahan bermanfaat Supplier Jual Besi Siku Baja Distributor Plat Kapal Besi baja Distributor plat besi hitam Harga besi wf Harga besi wf Agen besi hollow Agen besi siku undangan pernikahan ada fotonya Supplier Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal Supplier Plat Kapal Besi baja Harga plat besi hitam www.pusatbesibaja.co.id Jual besi wf Jual besi wf Agen besi beton Sni Ulir Polos Agen Plat besi plat kapal undangancinta.com Supplier Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording Agen Plat Kapal Besi baja Jual plat besi hitam www.pusatbesibaja.com Supplier besi wf Supplier besi wf ironsteelcenter.com Agen besi h beam baja undangan pernikahan cantik dan murah Supplier Besi Hollow Toko Plat Kapal Besi baja Pabrik Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording Pabrik Besi Siku Baja Pabrik besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton Distributor sch 40 Distributor sch 40 Supplier atap spandek Supplier wiremesh undangan pernikahan bunga Pabrik Besi Hollow Distributor Besi Unp Baja Distributor besi wf Harga sch 40 Harga sch 40 Supplier baja ringan Supplier pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan islami Pabrik Wiremesh Supplier Besi Unp Baja Harga besi wf

Posted by farchan ali on 4th December 2018 at 02:03pm

This article talks lot about the African continent and their life style. rates ofdeath funeral

Posted by DilROYL on 18th January 2019 at 05:34am

yes i am fully decided on amid this text and that i simply indulgent pronounce that this article is deeply best and pretty informative article.i will make hermetically sealed to be studying your blog extra. You made a fine lessening but I can't seasoned occurring but surprise, what kind of the including together facet? !!!!!!thank you!!!!!! Large package shipping Maryland

Posted by sohail khatri on 7th February 2019 at 12:50pm

i am glad i found this net site, I couldn't discover any know-how in terms of this difficulty prior to.additionally perform a domain and if you are ever eager in take steps some visitor writing for me if possible sense pardon to conform to me know, im usually see for human beings to test out my web site. w888 download

Posted by sohail khatri on 8th February 2019 at 08:09am

beautifully written article, if without help all bloggers presented the related content as you, the net could be a miles away and huge and wide and huge away afield afield away greater than before vicinity.. Web Design

Posted by sohail khatri on 9th February 2019 at 10:26am

thanks for this usefull article, expecting this text related to this taking into account once more. combat reloaded

Posted by sohail khatri on 12th February 2019 at 04:58pm

Its a cozy delight reading your claim.Its full of aspire i am looking for and i lionize to claim a comment that "The content material of your proclaim is incredible" extremely good accomplish. ladders for sale

Posted by sohail khatri on 13th February 2019 at 04:57pm

this is such a satisfying aid that you are supplying and you pay for it away for pardon. infervour

Posted by sohail khatri on 14th February 2019 at 09:09am

Wow its a very good post. The information provided by you is really very good and helpful for me. Terms of Use

Posted by massroids on 23rd February 2019 at 08:51am

i am glad i found this net site, I couldn't discover any know-how in terms of this difficulty prior to.additionally perform a domain and if you are ever eager in take steps some visitor writing for me if possible sense pardon to conform to me know, im usually see for human beings to test out my web site. C5 Cinnamon Exporter Sri Lanka

Posted by Bindas on 25th February 2019 at 05:25pm

I have read your blog it is very helpful for me. I want to say thanks to you. I have bookmark your site for future updates. http://www.lateet.com/

Posted by sohail khatri on 2nd March 2019 at 09:19am

I’m going to read this. I’ll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing. and also This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives indepth information. thanks for this nice article... AboutNutra

Posted by sohail khatri on 3rd March 2019 at 09:25am

Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. https://marketplace.seo-sa.com/1-dollar-services/

Posted by sohail khatri on 5th March 2019 at 08:06am

Well if you are looking to get free instagram followers Click here to Get Free Instagram Followers from iFreeGiveaways instantly.

Posted by Jessica Mike on 5th March 2019 at 09:09am

I admit, I have not been on this web page in a long time... however it was another joy to see It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues. Press Release

Posted by sohail khatri on 8th March 2019 at 01:19pm

I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information? check over here

Posted by sohail khatri on 10th March 2019 at 04:53pm

Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. infervour

Posted by sohail khatri on 17th March 2019 at 06:16pm

Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. infervour

Posted by sohail khatri on 26th March 2019 at 04:24pm

Awesome article, it was exceptionally helpful! I simply began in this and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Cheers, keep doing awesome!

Posted by AboutNutra on 12th April 2019 at 06:42pm

Awesome article, it was exceptionally helpful! I simply began in this and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Cheers, keep doing awesome! AboutNutra

Posted by sohail khatri on 13th April 2019 at 06:44pm

You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us to read this... infervour

Posted by sohail khatri on 13th April 2019 at 06:53pm

I have read your blog it is very helpful for me. I want to say thanks to you. I have bookmark your site for future updates. Local SEO

Posted by Reginald Massey on 15th April 2019 at 05:57pm

I'm glad I found this web site, I couldn't find any knowledge on this matter prior to.Also operate a site and if you are ever interested in doing some visitor writing for me if possible feel free to let me know, im always look for people to check out my web site. خرید بک لینک

Posted by sohail khatri on 16th April 2019 at 11:07am

Make a comment
Email will not be published
Put right answer (e.g. twenty-five)
Leave this field blank (antispam tool)